Raw Spread Vs Zero Spread

Category: Trading Guides | Author: Trading Brokers | Date: June 1, 2023

When it comes to forex trading, selecting the most suitable forex trading account is a crucial decision that can significantly impact your trading experience and potential profitability. Among the various account types available, two options often considered are raw spread accounts and zero spread accounts. In this article, we will delve into the differences between these two account types, examine their advantages and disadvantages, and empower you with the knowledge to make an informed decision. By understanding the features, benefits, and considerations associated with raw spread and zero spread accounts, you can unlock the choice that aligns with your trading goals and preferences.

What is a Raw Spread Account?

A raw spread account is a type of forex trading account where traders have direct access to the interbank market spreads. In this account, traders are offered spreads that reflect the actual market rates, with minimal markup or intervention from the broker. Raw spread accounts typically involve paying a separate commission on each trade. These accounts are favored by traders who value transparency, tight spreads, and direct market access.

Raw Spread Account Pros

  • Tight spreads based on actual market rates.
  • Transparency in pricing with real-time market spreads.
  • Direct market access for potentially better liquidity and trade execution.

Raw Spread Account Cons

  • Commission costs add to overall trading expenses.
  • Higher minimum deposit requirements may limit accessibility.
  • Requires a deeper understanding of trading costs for effective decision-making.

What is a Zero Spread Account?

A zero spread account is a type of forex trading account where traders pay a fixed commission instead of spreads. In this account, the broker offers zero spreads, meaning there is no difference between the bid and ask prices. However, traders are charged a fixed commission on each trade, which is typically higher than the spreads in traditional accounts. Zero spread accounts are designed to eliminate costs associated with small price movements and provide fixed trading costs for traders. They are often favored by scalpers and traders employing quick trading strategies that require a forex broker with low spreads at all times.

Zero Spread Account Pros

  • Fixed trading costs with no spreads.
  • Pricing transparency with separate commission charges.
  • Suitable for scalping strategies and quick trading.

Zero Spread Account Cons

  • Higher fixed commission fees compared to spreads.
  • Limited availability with some brokers.
  • Potential conflict of interest as brokers derive revenue from commissions.

Comparison between Raw Spread and Zero Spread Accounts

Now, let’s compare these two account types based on various factors with practical examples:

  1. Trading Costs: For Raw Spread Accounts, traders pay spreads plus commissions. For instance, Broker A offers a raw spread account with an average spread of 0.2 pips on EUR/USD and a commission of $7 per lot traded. On the other hand, for Zero Spread Accounts, traders pay fixed commissions. For example, Broker B offers a zero spread account with a fixed commission of $10 per lot traded on all currency pairs.
  2. Pricing Transparency: For Raw Spread Accounts, traders have access to transparent pricing with direct market spreads. Broker A displays real-time spreads of 0.2 pips for EUR/USD, reflecting the interbank market rates. On the other hand, for Zero Spread Accounts: Traders benefit from transparent pricing, with separate commission charges visible. Broker B displays zero spreads on EUR/USD but charges a fixed commission of $10 per lot traded.
  3. Accessibility: For Raw Spread Accounts, some brokers may require higher minimum deposit requirements. For example, Broker A has a minimum deposit requirement of $1,000 for their raw spread account. On the other hand, for Zero Spread Accounts, minimum deposit requirements may vary. Broker B offers a zero spread account with a minimum deposit of $100, making it more accessible to traders with limited capital.
  4. Scalping and Quick Trading: For Raw Spread Accounts, tight spreads and direct market access make raw spread accounts attractive for scalpers and high-frequency traders. For instance, Broker A’s raw spread account allows quick execution for scalping strategies. On the other hand, for Zero Spread Accounts, Zero spreads eliminate costs associated with small price movements, making them suitable for scalping. Broker B’s zero spread account is designed to cater to scalping strategies.
  5. Trade Execution: For Raw Spread Accounts,  direct market access can potentially result in faster trade execution and reduced slippage. Broker A’s raw spread account offers fast execution speeds and minimal slippage. On the other hand, for Zero Spread Accounts, trade execution quality can vary depending on the broker’s infrastructure and technology. Broker B’s zero spread account uses advanced technology to ensure efficient trade execution.

By considering these factors and practical examples, you can weigh the advantages and disadvantages of raw spread and zero spread accounts to determine which option aligns better with your trading style, goals, and financial circumstances.

Which Account is Better for You?

Determining the better account type depends on your specific trading preferences, strategies, and circumstances. Consider the following:

Go for a raw spread account if:

  • You value tight spreads and are willing to pay commissions for transparent and direct market access.
  • You are an active trader engaging in frequent trading activities.
  • You have sufficient capital to meet the minimum deposit requirements.

Opt for a zero spread account if:

  • You prefer fixed trading costs and are comfortable paying higher commissions instead of spreads.
  • You engage in scalping or quick trading strategies where eliminating spread-related costs is crucial.
  • You have a smaller trading capital and prefer lower minimum deposit requirements.

Conclusion

In conclusion, choosing between a raw spread account and a zero spread account requires careful consideration of trading costs, pricing transparency, accessibility, trading strategies, and your individual preferences. Assess your trading goals, evaluate the pros and cons of each account type, and select the one that aligns with your trading style, risk tolerance, and financial situation. Remember, the right account choice can significantly impact your overall trading experience and potential in the dynamic forex market. You can also see our guide on raw spreads vs standard spreads for further information.


Relevant Articles