Oanda Vs TradeStation

Category: Broker Guides | Author: Trading Brokers | Date: July 24, 2023

In today’s fast-paced financial landscape, choosing the right trading platform is crucial to your success. With countless options available, it can be overwhelming to determine which platform best aligns with your trading objectives. In this article, we’ll take an in-depth look at their backgrounds, evaluate their strengths and weaknesses, and explore their differences in terms of regulation, trading platform features, pricing and fees, broker type, leverage, asset selection, social trading capabilities, minimum deposit requirements, as well as withdrawal and deposit methods. By the end of our analysis, you’ll have the insights you need to make an informed decision about whether Oanda or TradeStation is the ideal platform to support your trading journey.

Overview of Oanda

Oanda

Oanda

Oanda is a well-established global forex broker founded in 1996. It has a presence in various countries including Canada, the US, the UK, Japan, Singapore, and Australia. Oanda is regulated by prominent authorities such as the IIROC, CFTC, FCA, FSA, and ASIC. Oanda boasts a comprehensive range of trading options to meet the diverse needs of its traders. With over 68 forex pairs available, traders can engage in various currency pairs to capitalize on global market opportunities. In addition to forex trading, Oanda offers Contracts for Difference (CFDs) on indices, commodities, metals, bonds, and even cryptocurrencies through its partnership with Paxos.

This provides traders with a diverse set of instruments to diversify their portfolios and explore different investment opportunities. Traders can access their proprietary web-based trading platform called OANDA Trade, as well as the widely used MetaTrader 4 (MT4) platform. Oanda provides valuable analysis tools, such as advanced charts powered by TradingView, Autochartist’s technical analysis, and an economic overlay. Additionally, Oanda offers a currency converter tool for checking exchange rates and converting major world currencies. Developers can also utilize Oanda’s FX data API to integrate forex data into their applications.

Pros of Oanda

  • Multiple regulatory authorities oversee Oanda’s operations across jurisdictions.
  • Forex pairs have low spreads.
  • No minimum deposit requirement for account opening.
  • Access to crypto trading is available through Paxos.
  • A wide variety of analysis tools and educational resources are provided.

Cons of Oanda

  • Asset selection is more limited compared to other brokers.
  • CFDs and crypto trading incur high fees.
  • Social trading and copy trading features are not available.
Oanda Logo

Oanda is a multi-regulated and established online broker offering an excellent range of financial instruments via powerful and user-friendly trading platforms with industry leading trading conditions and a superb selection of premium trading tools for comprehensive market analysis.

Leveraged trading in foreign currency contracts or other off-exchange products on margin carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for everyone.

Overview of TradeStation

TradeStation

TradeStation

TradeStation is a US online brokerage firm that was founded in 1982 and is headquartered in Plantation, Florida. TradeStation is regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) and the CFTC. TradeStation offers a wide range of trading products and services, such as stocks, ETFs, options, futures, forex and crypto. The platform offers a web-based trading platform known as TradeStation Trading Platform, as well as a comprehensive desktop platform called TradeStation Desktop Platform. To ensure convenient trading, TradeStation also provides a mobile app that allows users to trade while on the go. Recognizing the importance of advanced tools and research, TradeStation equips users with a variety of features to enhance their trading experience. These features include market data packages, customizable watchlists, real-time alerts, powerful screeners, comprehensive news feeds, and insightful reports. By providing these tools and research capabilities, TradeStation empowers traders to make informed decisions based on real-time market information.

Pros of TradeStation

  • $0 commissions on stock, ETF, and options trades
  • High-powered trading platform with advanced tools and automation
  • Wide range of investment options, including crypto
  • Free market data and no monthly platform charges for TS Select clients
  • Active trader community and dedicated customer service

Cons of TradeStation

  • Steep learning curve for beginners
  • No fractional shares, DRIPs, or forex trading
  • High fees for non-free mutual funds, futures contracts, and wire transfers
  • No third-party fundamental research or everyday investor education
  • Confusing pricing structure with multiple plans, tiers, and add-ons
TradeStation Logo

TradeStation have an excellent proprietary platform, vast range of robust tools and learning resources for active traders to trade thousands of instruments online with low commission fees.

All investments involve risk, including loss of principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Comparison between Oanda and TradeStation

In this section, we will compare Oanda and TradeStation based on the following features:

Regulation

Both Oanda and TradeStation are regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) in the US, providing up to $500k coverage to US clients. However, Oanda offers additional regulatory coverage for clients in other countries, including the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) in the UK with £85k protection, the Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada (IIROC) in Canada with CAD 1mn protection, and the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) in Australia. In contrast, TradeStation lacks any regulatory licenses outside the US, potentially leaving clients from other countries without investor compensation schemes.

Trading Platform

Both Oanda and TradeStation offer the MT4 platform and have their own web-based trading platforms that are user-friendly and customizable. Oanda’s platform is called OANDA Trade, while TradeStation’s platform is called TradeStation Trading Platform. Both platforms allow you to trade forex, CFDs, and crypto, as well as access various analysis tools and market data. However, Oanda’s platform has some features that TradeStation’s platform lacks, such as advanced charts powered by TradingView, technical analysis from Autochartist, and an economic overlay. TradeStation’s platform, on the other hand, has some features that Oanda’s platform lacks, such as watchlists, alerts, screeners, and news feeds.

Pricing and Fees

Both Oanda and TradeStation have competitive pricing and fees for forex trading. Oanda charges low spreads on forex pairs, starting from 0.6 pips for EUR/USD. TradeStation charges variable spreads on forex pairs, starting from 1.0 pips for EUR/USD. However, TradeStation also charges a commission of $0.10 per 1,000 units traded on top of the spread. Therefore, Oanda has an edge over TradeStation in terms of forex fees. Oanda charges high spreads on CFDs and crypto, starting from 2 pips for US 500 index and 0.75% for Bitcoin. TradeStation charges lower spreads on CFDs and crypto, starting from 0.5 pips for US 500 index and 0.25% for Bitcoin. TradeStation also charges a commission of $0.10 per contract traded on CFDs and $1 per unit traded on crypto.

Broker Type

Oanda and TradeStation are both market makers that also offer direct market access (DMA) to their clients. This means that they can act as both a counterparty to their clients’ trades or route their orders to liquidity providers such as banks or exchanges. Oanda is a no dealing desk (NDD) broker that uses a hybrid model of electronic communication network (ECN) and straight through processing (STP) to execute its clients’ orders. TradeStation is a dealing desk (DD) broker that uses an agency model to execute its clients’ orders through its own market-making subsidiary or third-party liquidity providers.

Leverage

Oanda and TradeStation have similar leverage options for forex trading, but they may differ for other instruments and regions. Oanda offers leverage up to 50:1 for major currency pairs and up to 20:1 for minor currency pairs, commodities, indices, and stocks. TradeStation also offers leverage up to 50:1 for major currency pairs and up to 20:1 for minor and exotic pairs.

Asset Selection

Both Oanda and TradeStation offer a decent range of assets to trade with. Oanda offers over 68 forex pairs, as well as CFDs on indices, commodities, metals, bonds, and crypto through its partnership with Paxos. TradeStation offers a wide range of trading products and services, such as stocks, ETFs, options, futures, forex, and crypto. However, TradeStation has more asset classes than Oanda, such as stocks, ETFs, options, and futures.

Social Trading

Oanda and TradeStation have different approaches to social trading. Oanda does not offer any social trading features on its platforms, but it allows its clients to connect their accounts to third-party social trading platforms such as ZuluTrade and DupliTrade. TradeStation offers its own social trading platform called TradeStation Community, where clients can interact with other traders, share ideas and strategies, follow experts, and copy trades.

Minimum Deposit

Oanda offers the advantage of no minimum deposit requirement, allowing traders to start with any desired amount, although fees may apply from payment providers. TradeStation has no minimum deposit requirement for its web trading platform or its mobile app but requires a minimum deposit of $2,000 for its desktop platform (or $10 per trade if below that amount).

Withdrawal and Deposit Methods

Both Oanda and TradeStation offer various payment methods for funding your account, but there are differences in their options. Oanda accepts debit card, bank transfer, PayPal, Neteller, Skrill, and other methods based on your country of residence. Additionally, you can transfer funds between your Oanda wallet and trading account at any time. On the other hand, TradeStation solely accepts bank wire transfer as a payment method and allows withdrawals exclusively through bank wire transfer. Both brokers require you to use the same method for withdrawal as the one used for funding your account.

Which Should You Choose: Oanda or TradeStation?

The answer to this question depends on your trading preferences and goals. Here are some factors to consider when choosing between Oanda and TradeStation: If you are looking for a global and regulated broker that offers low spreads on forex pairs and access to crypto trading, you might prefer Oanda. If you are looking for a US-based and reputable broker that offers commission-free trading on stocks, ETFs and options and access to a wide range of trading products and services, you might prefer TradeStation. If you are looking for a broker that offers leverage for forex and CFD trading, you might prefer Oanda, especially if you are not based in the US.

Also, If you are looking for a broker that offers more asset classes to trade with, such as stocks, ETFs, options and futures, you might prefer TradeStation.

If you are looking for a broker that offers social trading or copy trading features, you might be disappointed with both Oanda and TradeStation, as they do not offer these features on their platforms. However, TradeStation’s desktop platform TradeStation Desktop Platform has a social trading feature called myTrade. If you are looking for a broker that has no minimum deposit requirement, you might prefer Oanda, as TradeStation requires a minimum deposit of $2,000 or an electronic funding of $100 per month.

Conclusion

In conclusion, we have examined two reputable and popular online brokers, Oanda and TradeStation, which offer distinct features and services to their clients. Each broker has its own strengths and weaknesses, catering to different types of traders. Therefore, it is essential to carefully compare them based on your specific trading preferences and goals before making a final decision. Throughout this article, we have provided insights into the differences between Oanda and TradeStation, empowering you to choose the broker that aligns best with your needs. By considering factors such as regulation, trading features, pricing and fees, and other relevant aspects, you can make an informed choice. Ultimately, the decision of selecting the best broker for you lies in your hands. Here’s to your success and enjoyment in your trading journey! Happy trading!


Relevant Articles