Oanda Vs Alpari

Category: Broker Guides | Author: Trading Brokers | Date: July 22, 2023

When it comes to forex and CFD trading, Oanda and Alpari are two well-established investment management companies that offer a range of services to traders worldwide. In this comparison, we will delve into the key aspects of each platform, including their regulatory framework, trading platforms, asset selection, levers, and other relevant factors. By examining these factors, investors can gain a comprehensive understanding of the strengths and differences between Oanda and Alpari, allowing them to make an informed decision based on their specific trading preferences and goals. Whether you are an experienced trader or just starting in the world of financial markets, understanding the nuances of each platform is crucial for finding the right fit for your trading needs.

Overview of Oanda

Oanda

Oanda

Oanda is a well-established investment management company based in the United States, offering forex and CFD trading services to clients globally. The company operates under the regulatory oversight of top-tier financial authorities, including the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). This regulatory framework ensures a high level of investor protection and transparency.

Oanda provides a comprehensive range of investment products, including forex, CFDs, commodities, bonds, and indices. The platform offers competitive spreads, allowing traders to access the markets at competitive pricing. With its user-friendly trading platform, Oanda equips traders with a variety of tools and resources to make informed decisions. Traders can choose from the popular MetaTrader 4 (MT4) platform or Oanda’s proprietary webtrader. Additionally, Oanda stands out by offering an upgrade to its webtrader that includes 28 trading tools, providing traders with advanced functionalities and features.

Pros of Oanda

  • Regulated by top-tier financial authorities (CFTC and FCA)
  • Wide range of investment products including forex, CFDs, commodities, bonds, and indices
  • Competitive spreads on trading instruments
  • User-friendly trading platform with advanced tools and resources

Cons of Oanda

  • It does not offer negative balance protection for US clients, which means you could lose more than your account balance if the market moves against you.
  • It charges an inactivity fee of $10 per month after 12 months of no trading activity.
  • It has average CFD fees compared to other brokers, and the fees are not very transparent as they are built into the spread.
Oanda Logo

Oanda is a multi-regulated and established online broker offering an excellent range of financial instruments via powerful and user-friendly trading platforms with industry leading trading conditions and a superb selection of premium trading tools for comprehensive market analysis.

Leveraged trading in foreign currency contracts or other off-exchange products on margin carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for everyone.

Overview of Alpari

Alpari

Alpari

Alpari is a veteran forex and CFD broker that has been in the business since 1998. Starting from Russia, it has expanded its reach to over 150 countries, offering a variety of trading platforms and instruments to suit different needs and preferences. Whether you want to trade currency pairs, cryptocurrencies, stocks, indices, or commodities, Alpari has something for you. You can also benefit from its rebates and cashback, automated trading, copy trading, and educational services. Alpari is regulated by different authorities in different regions, such as the IFSC of Belize, the FSA of St. Vincent and the Grenadines, and the FSC of Mauritius.

However, it does not have any top-tier regulators, such as the FCA or ASIC, which may raise some concerns about its safety and reputation. Alpari has also faced some insolvency and regulatory issues in the past, especially in its UK entity, which went bankrupt in 2015 after the Swiss franc shock. On the bright side, Alpari has a charitable fund that supports social causes, such as helping children, families, and sports. Alpari is a broker with a long history and a wide range of services, but also with some drawbacks and challenges.

Pros of Alpari

  • User-friendly, simple, and easy-to-use platform
  • Account options for both beginners and the pro
  • A competitive trading condition that perfectly fits with the ongoing demand of both novice and pro traders

Cons of Alpari

  • Not regulated by any top-tier regulatory body
  • Does not accept clients from some countries
  • Charges high spreads and commissions on some financial assets
  • Does not provide 24/7 live chat support
Alpari Logo

Alpari is an online brokerage firm with a global client base, range of flexible trading platforms, investor accounts and trading tools. However, regulation could be improved as could the number of trading instruments offered.

Between 74-89% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.

Comparison Between Oanda and Alpari

Let’s delve into a comprehensive comparison based on several key considerations, examining the strengths and nuances of each platform.

Regulation

OANDA is regulated by multiple top-tier authorities, including the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), and the National Futures Association (NFA). On the other hand, Alpari is regulated by the Financial Services Authority (FSA) in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines. Alpari is also regulated by the FSC in Mauritius, which is considered a low-tier authority. While OANDA is subject to stringent regulatory oversight across major financial markets, Alpari’s regulatory framework appears to be focused on specific jurisdictions. This could impact the level of investor protection and transparency offered by the two brokers.

Trading platforms

Oanda offers a diverse range of trading platforms to cater to different trading preferences. Apart from its proprietary platform, Oanda provides access to popular platforms like MetaTrader 4 (MT4) and MetaTrader 5 (MT5). These platforms offer advanced charting tools, technical analysis indicators, automated trading options, and a user-friendly interface. Similarly, Alpari offers its own proprietary platform, alongside MT4 and MT5, ensuring clients have access to a wide selection of trading platforms suitable for their needs.

Pricing and fees

When considering pricing and fees, Oanda charges only spreads, providing competitive pricing for most traders on its forex and CFD trades. However, it has an inactivity fee of $10 per month after 12 months of no trading activity. On the other hand, Alpari charges both spreads and commissions, with higher spreads and variable commissions ranging from $3 to $16 per round lot, depending on the account type and trading volume. While Alpari does not impose an inactivity fee, it does charge deposit and withdrawal fees, potentially increasing overall trading costs and reducing profitability.

Broker Type

Oanda is a market maker broker, which means it acts as the counterparty to its clients’ trades. Oanda uses a hybrid model of dealing desk (DD) and no dealing desk (NDD) execution, depending on the account type and trading platform. Oanda claims to offer transparent pricing and fair execution to its clients.

Alpari on the other hand, is an NDD broker, which means it does not act as the counterparty to its clients’ trades. Alpari uses different types of execution models depending on the account type and trading platform. Alpari offers electronic communication network (ECN) and straight-through processing (STP) execution for some accounts, which provide direct access to the interbank market and liquidity providers.

Leverage

Oanda and Alpari offer leverage options to enhance trading opportunities. Oanda provides leverage up to 50:1 for retail clients and up to 100:1 for professional clients. On the other hand, Alpari offers leverage up to 30:1 for retail clients and up to 1000:1 for professional clients. Leverage allows traders to control larger positions in the market with a smaller initial capital investment. However, it’s crucial to understand the risks associated with high leverage and use it responsibly.

Asset selection

Oanda and Alpari have different asset selections that affect their trading opportunities and diversification. Oanda offers only forex and CFD trading, with 124 tradeable symbols in total, including 71 forex pairs. Oanda also offers cryptocurrency trading, both physical and CFD, which is a rare feature among forex brokers. However, Oanda does not offer any non-CFD trading, such as U.S. or international stocks, which limits its appeal to some traders. Alpari offers forex, CFD, and non-CFD trading, with 105 tradeable symbols in total, including 46 forex pairs. Alpari also offers cryptocurrency trading, but only as CFDs. Alpari does offer non-CFD trading, such as international stocks, which expands its appeal to some traders. However, Alpari has fewer tradeable symbols and forex pairs than Oanda, which reduces its trading opportunities and diversification.

Social Trading

Alpari offers more social trading features than Oanda, such as PAMM accounts and Alpari CopyTrade. PAMM accounts allow traders to invest in the strategies of experienced managers and share the profits or losses. Alpari CopyTrade allows traders to copy the trades of successful traders and pay a commission or a percentage of the profits. Oanda does not offer any social trading or copy trading features, which limits its appeal to traders who want to follow or learn from others. However, Oanda offers social trading via ZuluTrade, a third-party platform that connects traders with signal providers. Oanda also supports TradingView, which brings endless charting possibilities and a social aspect to online trading activity.

Minimum Deposit

Regarding minimum deposit requirements, Oanda does not have a minimum deposit for its standard account, making it accessible to traders of any budget. There are no deposit or withdrawal fees, adding to its affordability. In contrast, Alpari has a minimum deposit requirement of $100 for its standard account, with additional deposit and withdrawal fees depending on the method. However, Alpari offers a micro account with a minimum deposit of $5, catering to beginners or low-budget traders. They also have higher-tier accounts like ECN and MT4 Pro with varying minimum deposits suited for advanced or professional traders.

Withdrawal and Deposit methods

Oanda and Alpari offer multiple options for depositing and withdrawing funds. Oanda accepts various methods, including bank transfers, credit/debit cards, PayPal, and Skrill. However, the availability of these methods may vary depending on the trader’s country of residence. Similarly, Alpari accepts bank transfers, credit/debit cards, Neteller, and Skrill for deposits. Withdrawals can be made via bank transfer or e-wallets such as Neteller or Skrill. It’s important for traders to review the available methods and consider any associated fees or processing times when choosing their preferred deposit and withdrawal options.

Which is Better For You?

Oanda might be a better option for traders who value a wide range of investment products and access to multiple markets. With its comprehensive selection of investment options including forex, CFDs, commodities, bonds, and indices, Oanda provides ample opportunities for diversification. Additionally, Oanda’s advanced trading platforms, particularly its proprietary webtrader with 28 trading tools, offer enhanced functionality for traders seeking sophisticated trading strategies. The low spreads on offer, particularly for major currency pairs like EUR/USD, make Oanda an attractive choice for cost-effective forex trading. Moreover, traders who value round-the-clock customer support can benefit from Oanda’s 24/7 customer service, ensuring assistance is available at any time.

On the other hand, Alpari may be a better fit for traders who prioritize simplicity and reliability in their trading experience. The availability of the widely-used MetaTrader 4 (MT4) and MetaTrader 5 (MT5) platforms provides a familiar and user-friendly interface for traders. While Alpari offers a narrower range of investment products compared to Oanda, it covers popular asset classes such as forex, CFDs, commodities, indices, and cryptocurrencies. Traders who appreciate access to basic versions of these platforms and the peace of mind provided by regulation under the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) may find Alpari to be a suitable choice.

Conclusion

In conclusion, both Oanda and Alpari offer competitive trading services with their unique strengths and advantages. Oanda stands out with its wide range of investment products, advanced trading platforms, and low spreads, making it an attractive choice for traders seeking diversification and sophisticated trading tools. On the other hand, Alpari’s focus on simplicity, reliability, and regulation, along with its provision of popular trading platforms, makes it a suitable option for traders who prefer a straightforward and user-friendly experience. Ultimately, traders should carefully consider their individual needs, trading preferences, and goals to determine which platform aligns best with their requirements.


Relevant Articles