IG Vs Stake

Category: Broker Guides | Author: Trading Brokers | Date: July 22, 2023

In the realm of online trading, investors have numerous platforms to choose from, each offering unique features and advantages that cater to different trading needs and preferences. In this article, we will conduct a comprehensive comparison between IG and Stake, two prominent players in the trading industry. By examining their key attributes, including trading platforms, fees, asset selection, deposit and withdrawal methods, as well as additional features, we aim to assist you in making an informed decision on which platform aligns best with your individual trading goals. So, let’s delve into the offerings of IG and Stake, analyzing their strengths and limitations to determine the optimal choice for your trading endeavors.

Overview of IG

IG

IG

IG, a renowned trading platform, distinguishes itself by providing access to an extensive range of markets and products. With two of the best trading platforms available, the user-friendly IG Trading Platform and the widely used MetaTrader 4 (MT4) platform, IG caters to a diverse range of traders. The web-based IG Trading Platform offers an intuitive interface and customizable features, empowering users to tailor their trading environment. The MT4 platform, popular among traders globally, provides advanced charting tools and automated trading features.

One of IG’s standout features is its market coverage, granting access to over 17,000 markets across various asset classes, such as forex, shares, indices, commodities, cryptocurrencies, and more. Traders can leverage IG’s research tools, including news feeds, market analysis, and trading signals, to stay informed about market trends and make well-informed decisions. Additionally, IG places a strong emphasis on education, offering a range of resources such as webinars, courses, and comprehensive trading guides, to equip traders with the necessary knowledge and skills. With customer support available through multiple channels, including phone, email, and live chat, IG ensures prompt assistance to address any concerns or queries.

Pros of IG

  • Wide range of markets and products
  • User-friendly web-based and MT4 trading platforms
  • Advanced charting tools and customizable interface
  • Extensive research tools, including news feeds and market analysis
  • Access to third-party research from reputable providers

Cons of IG

  • Higher fees compared to Stake
  • Limited market coverage to the US market
IG Logo

IG have an impressive selection of 18,000+ instruments including Forex, Stocks, Cryptos and Commodities. You can trade via easy to use platforms for desktop and mobile apps, with low trading costs and the peace of mind that you are using one of the most well-known brokers in the industry.

69% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading spread bets and CFDs with this provider.

Overview of Stake

Stake

Stake

Stake, a trading platform tailored to beginner investors, focuses on providing stock and ETF trading on US markets at low fees. The account opening process with Stake is seamless and fully online, offering a streamlined onboarding experience. Stake’s user-friendly and well-designed trading platforms enable users to navigate the platform with ease, facilitating smooth trade execution. While Stake’s market coverage is limited to the US market, it provides access to a diverse range of over 6,000 US stocks and ETFs, including globally renowned companies like Apple, Google, and Amazon.

Traders on Stake must consider that all trades are conducted solely in US dollars, which may impact currency conversion costs and expose users to fluctuations in exchange rates. Despite this limitation, Stake offers a global trading experience, extending its reach to countries such as Australia, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, and Brazil. Traders can benefit from features like fractional shares, allowing them to invest in companies with high stock prices without the need to purchase a whole share. Stake also offers instant trades, providing traders with immediate execution and access to market opportunities without delays. Additionally, Stake offers auto-investing functionality, enabling users to automate their investment strategies and effortlessly grow their portfolios.

Pros of Stake

  • Low fees, including Australia’s cheapest CHESS-sponsored brokerage starting at just $3 per trade
  • User-friendly and well-designed trading platforms
  • Access to a diverse range of US stocks and ETFs
  • Features like fractional shares, instant trades, and auto-investing
  • Seamless account opening process

Cons of Stake

  • Limited market coverage restricted to the US market
  • All trades conducted solely in US dollars, potentially incurring currency conversion costs and exposing users to exchange rate fluctuations
Stake Logo

Stake is an Australian-based trading broker that enables traders and investors to access a great selection of over 8,000 US Stocks and ETFs via a user-friendly mobile app.

All investments involve risk, including loss of principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Comparison Between IG and Stake

Let’s delve into a detailed comparison between IG and Stake, assisting you in making an informed decision about which trading platform is better suited for your individual needs.

Regulation

IG and Stake differ in terms of their regulatory oversight. IG falls under the regulation of ASIC, FCA, MAS, and CFTC, offering traders a multi-layered security framework. On the other hand, Stake is regulated solely by ASIC and FCA. This indicates that IG has a wider scope of regulatory compliance across various jurisdictions compared to Stake’s focus primarily on ASIC and FCA regulation.

Trading platforms

IG offers its users a choice between its proprietary trading platform, and MetaTrader 4 (MT4), a popular third-party platform widely used in the industry. The proprietary platform is designed to provide a comprehensive trading experience, while MT4 offers advanced charting tools, automated trading capabilities, and access to a large community of traders through its marketplace. On the other hand, Stake offers a trading app that is user-friendly with search functions, price alerts, and order types.

Pricing and fees

IG charges commissions for stock and ETF trading on US markets, which are either $3 per trade up to $30,000 or 0.01% per trade above $30,000. IG also charges forex conversion fees on deposits and withdrawals, which are 0.5% for major currencies and 1% for minor currencies. IG does not charge any inactivity fees or withdrawal fees.

Stake offers commission-free stock and ETF trading on US markets, which means that there are no fees for opening or closing trades. However, Stake also charges forex conversion fees on deposits and withdrawals, which are 0.7% for major currencies and 1% for minor currencies. Stake also charges a monthly subscription fee for its premium plans, which range from $9 to $19 per month. Stake does not charge any inactivity fees or withdrawal fees either.

Both IG and Stake have low-fee structures that are competitive and transparent. However, Stake may be more attractive for traders who want to save on commissions, while IG may be more suitable for traders who want to access more markets and products.

Broker Type

IG operates as a market maker broker, meaning that it acts as the counterparty to its clients’ trades. Stake, on the other hand, functions as a broker but utilizes DriveWealth as its clearing broker. DriveWealth is responsible for executing and settling trades on behalf of Stake’s clients, providing an added layer of security and efficiency in the trade execution process.

Leverage

IG offers leverage options for its clients, allowing them to trade larger positions with a smaller initial capital investment. Retail clients can access leverage of up to 30:1, while professional clients can access higher leverage of up to 200:1. On the other hand, Stake does not offer leverage, which means trades are executed based on the funds available in the user’s account without the ability to amplify exposure through borrowed capital.

Asset selection

IG provides a comprehensive range of tradable assets across various markets. Traders can access forex, shares, indices, commodities, cryptocurrencies, options, ETFs, bonds, and interest rates, allowing for diverse investment opportunities. Stake, on the other hand, focuses primarily on shares and ETFs, making it a suitable choice for those interested in investing in specific stocks or exchange-traded funds.

Social Trading

IG offers social trading functionality through its platform called IG Community. This feature allows traders to connect, share trading ideas, and discuss market trends. It provides a platform for beginners to learn from experienced traders and for experienced traders to showcase their expertise. In contrast, Stake does not offer social trading, which means users do not have access to a dedicated social trading community within the platform.

Minimum Deposit

The minimum deposit for IG is $0 for bank transfers and $300 for credit/debit cards and PayPal.  However, IG does recommend that traders deposit at least $250 or equivalent to cover the margins of their first trades. The minimum deposit for Stake is $50. This means that you can start trading with IG without any minimum deposit if you use a bank transfer, but you need to deposit at least $50 to start trading with Stake.

Withdrawal and Deposit methods

IG offers multiple options for both deposits and withdrawals, providing flexibility to its users. Traders can use bank transfers, credit/debit cards, PayPal, and Skrill for their deposits and withdrawals. However, the availability of specific methods may vary depending on the country of residence. Stake, on the other hand, allows deposits via bank transfers and debit/credit cards. Withdrawals, however, can only be made via bank transfer, limiting the available options for cashing out funds.

Which is better for you?

If you prioritize access to a wide range of markets and products, advanced research tools, and comprehensive educational resources, IG might be the better option for you. With over 17,000 markets across various asset classes, IG offers ample opportunities for diversification. Their research tools, including news feeds, market analysis, and trading signals, provide valuable insights for informed decision-making. Moreover, IG’s commitment to education through webinars, courses, and trading guides equips traders with the necessary knowledge and skills. If you value market variety, extensive research capabilities, and a strong educational foundation, IG could be the optimal choice for you.

On the other hand, if you prioritize low fees, user-friendly platforms, and a focus on US stock and ETF trading, Stake might be the better option for you. Stake offers competitive fees, including Australia’s cheapest CHESS-sponsored brokerage, which appeals to cost-conscious traders. Their user-friendly and well-designed trading platforms facilitate seamless navigation and trade execution. With access to a diverse range of US stocks and ETFs, including well-known global companies, Stake provides opportunities for targeted investments. If low fees, simplicity, and a niche focus on the US market align with your trading preferences, Stake could be the ideal choice for you.

Conclusion

In conclusion, both IG and Stake offer unique features and advantages within the trading landscape. IG stands out with its wide range of markets, advanced research tools, comprehensive educational resources, and access to multiple trading platforms. On the other hand, Stake specializes in low-cost US stock and ETF trading, providing a seamless and user-friendly experience. The choice between IG and Stake ultimately depends on your specific trading priorities and preferences. Evaluating factors such as market coverage, research capabilities, educational resources, fees, and platform focus will enable you to make an informed decision and select the platform that best aligns with your individual trading needs.


Relevant Articles