City Index Vs Oanda

Category: Broker Guides | Author: Trading Brokers | Date: June 26, 2023

In the realm of online trading platforms, two prominent names have emerged as go-to options for traders seeking a robust and reliable experience: City Index and Oanda. These platforms have garnered attention and praise for their comprehensive features, user-friendly interfaces, and extensive market coverage. Traders across the globe have found solace in their services, leveraging their powerful tools to navigate the intricate world of financial markets. In this article, we will delve into the similarities, differences, strengths, and weaknesses of City Index and Oanda, shedding light on the factors that make them stand out and assist you in making an informed decision for your trading journey.

Overview of City Index

City Index

City Index

City Index is a renowned online trading platform that provides access to a wide range of financial instruments, including forex, stocks, indices, commodities, and cryptocurrencies. With over 35 years of experience, City Index offers a robust and user-friendly interface, empowering traders to execute trades with speed and efficiency. Their advanced charting tools, customizable trading platforms, and comprehensive market analysis enable traders to make informed decisions. For instance, a forex trader can utilize City Index’s platform to analyze currency pairs, monitor economic indicators, and execute trades with tight spreads and competitive pricing.

Pros of City Index

  • City Index offers access to a diverse selection of financial markets, including forex, indices, shares, commodities, and cryptocurrencies, allowing traders to diversify their portfolios.
  • The platform provides traders with a variety of advanced tools, such as charting packages, technical analysis indicators, and risk management features, enabling users to make well-informed trading decisions.
  • City Index’s Price Improvement Technology helps traders obtain better execution prices on their trades, potentially maximizing their profits.
  • City Index offers comprehensive educational resources, including webinars, tutorials, and market analysis, to help traders enhance their knowledge and skills.

Cons of City Index

  • Some users have reported challenges in accessing timely and responsive customer support from City Index, which can be frustrating during critical trading moments.
  • City Index imposes inactivity fees on dormant accounts, which may be a concern for infrequent traders.
  • City Index does not accept clients from the United States, limiting its availability to traders from this region.
  • The fee structure of City Index can be complex, with various charges and spreads that may require careful attention to understand the costs associated with trading.
City Index Logo

City Index is a one of the world’s leading trading brokers offering thousands of financial instruments to traders worldwide. They have many years of experience, offering fast and reliable trade execution speeds, tight spreads and award-winning trading platforms.

69% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.

Overview of Oanda



Oanda is a prominent online trading platform that offers a wide range of financial instruments for traders, including forex, commodities, indices, bonds, and metals. With a strong reputation in the industry, Oanda has gained popularity for its user-friendly interface, competitive spreads, and reliable execution. Traders benefit from advanced charting tools, customizable indicators, and access to historical data for thorough analysis. For example, Oanda’s platform features the Order Book tool, which provides insights into market sentiment and order flow. With a focus on transparency, Oanda also offers a robust research portal, including economic news, market analysis, and educational resources, empowering traders with valuable information to make informed trading decisions.

Pros of Oanda

  • Oanda offers a user-friendly trading platform that is easy to navigate, making it accessible for traders of all experience levels.
  • The platform provides access to a wide range of financial instruments, including forex pairs, commodities, indices, and precious metals, allowing traders to diversify their portfolios.
  • Oanda is known for its transparent pricing model, providing competitive spreads and avoiding hidden fees, ensuring traders have a clear understanding of their trading costs.
  • Traders can access the Oanda Marketplace, which offers a range of third-party tools and apps to enhance the trading experience.

Cons of Oanda

  • Oanda’s research tools may be relatively basic compared to other platforms, which may be a drawback for traders who heavily rely on in-depth market analysis.
  • Some users have reported challenges in receiving timely and satisfactory customer support from Oanda, which can be frustrating during critical trading moments.
  • Oanda imposes inactivity fees on dormant accounts, which may be a concern for infrequent traders.
  • Oanda does not offer direct trading of US stocks, limiting its availability for traders who wish to invest specifically in US equities.
Oanda Logo

Oanda is a multi-regulated and established online broker offering an excellent range of financial instruments via powerful and user-friendly trading platforms with industry leading trading conditions and a superb selection of premium trading tools for comprehensive market analysis.

Leveraged trading in foreign currency contracts or other off-exchange products on margin carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for everyone.

Comparing City Index and Oanda

When comparing City Index and Oanda, it’s important to take into account several key factors. Let’s delve into each point in detail:


City Index and OANDA are regulated by esteemed authorities such as the FCA, ASIC, MAS, and DFSA for City Index, and the FCA, ASIC, MAS, CFTC/NFA, FSA, FSC, and MFSA for OANDA. This showcases their commitment to regulatory compliance, ensuring a high level of safety for traders. The extensive regulation surrounding both platforms instills confidence in their reliability and adherence to industry standards, offering traders peace of mind when engaging in trading activities.

Trading Platforms

City Index and OANDA provide a range of trading platforms to suit different preferences. City Index offers MetaTrader 4, NinjaTrader, Web Trader, and AT Pro, providing advanced tools and real-time data for efficient analysis and trading. OANDA offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, OANDA’s proprietary platform, and the FxTrade App, known for user-friendly interfaces, comprehensive features, and accessibility on multiple devices.

Pricing and Fees

When it comes to pricing and fees, City Index offers a variable spread model with no commission for its Standard pricing, while their Core pricing includes a commission of $50 per million traded. On the other hand, OANDA adopts a fixed spread model with no commission charges for its Standard pricing, and they also provide Core pricing with a commission of $50 per million traded. Traders have the flexibility to choose the pricing structure that best suits their trading style and preferences, whether it’s fixed or variable spreads.

Broker Type

Both City Index and OANDA operate as market maker brokers. As market makers, they provide liquidity for traders by offering bid and ask prices for various financial instruments. This allows for faster order execution and ensures that traders can enter and exit positions more easily.


City Index offers leverage of up to 1:30, allowing traders to amplify their positions. This leverage ratio varies depending on the instrument being traded and is subject to regulatory restrictions. OANDA offers leverage of up to 1:20, enabling traders to magnify their trading positions, albeit at a lower ratio compared to City Index. It’s important to note that high leverage carries risks and should be used with caution.

Asset Selection

City Index offers a diverse range of assets, such as forex, CFDs, spread betting, indices, commodities, bonds, options, and cryptocurrencies. Similarly, OANDA provides an extensive selection of assets, including forex, CFDs, spread betting, indices, commodities, bonds, binary options, ETFs, shares, physical stock, and cryptocurrencies. Both platforms cater to traders’ diverse needs by offering a broad array of tradable instruments.

Social Trading

Both City Index and OANDA prioritize social trading, connecting traders, and enabling trade replication. Social trading fosters learning, collaboration, and strategy enhancement. Both platforms offer tools for copy trading, allowing beginners to enter the market and busy traders to effortlessly diversify their portfolios by automatically copying selected traders’ trades.

Minimum Deposit

City Index sets a minimum deposit of $250, making it accessible to traders with smaller capital. In contrast, OANDA has no minimum deposit requirement, allowing traders to start with any amount they prefer, which is especially attractive to beginners or those wishing to test the platform before committing larger investments.

Withdrawal and Deposit methods

City Index and OANDA offer convenient payment methods such as wire transfer, credit/debit cards, Visa, Mastercard, ACH transfers, and bank transfers. Traders can benefit from their regulated status, trading platforms, pricing structures, market maker model, leverage options, asset selections, social trading support, flexible deposit requirements, and convenient payment methods. Consider these factors when making an informed trading decision.

City Index or Oanda: Which is Best For You?

If you’re a trader looking to decide between City Index and Oanda, there are a few important factors to consider. Firstly, both platforms are highly reputable and trusted in the industry, providing a secure trading environment. Secondly, their proprietary trading platforms offer advanced features, intuitive interfaces, and access to real-time market data, ensuring a seamless trading experience. Additionally, both platforms offer a wide range of tradable assets, including stocks, commodities, and cryptocurrencies, allowing you to diversify your portfolio. Furthermore, social trading features on both platforms enable you to connect with other traders and learn from their strategies. When it comes to pricing and fees, both City Index and Oanda offer competitive structures, ensuring reasonable trading costs. Finally, consider your specific requirements, such as minimum deposit amounts and leverage options, as these may vary between the two platforms. Assessing these factors will help you make an informed decision based on your individual trading preferences and goals.


In conclusion, both City Index and Oanda offer reputable and feature-rich online trading platforms, making them viable choices for traders. Each platform excels in certain areas, such as City Index’s extensive market coverage and advanced trading tools, and Oanda’s transparent pricing and social trading features. Ultimately, the decision between City Index and Oanda will depend on individual preferences, trading goals, and specific requirements. Traders should carefully consider factors like regulation, trading platform usability, pricing and fees, asset selection, and additional features offered by each platform. By evaluating these factors, traders can select the platform that aligns best with their needs and trading style, enabling them to embark on a successful trading journey.

Relevant Articles